Skip to content

Schafer & Schafer

Case Results

Verdicts & Settlements

* Represents cases where the attorneys recovered the statutory cap on damages pursuant to the Indiana Medical Malpractice Act.

$32,500,000.00 – 31-year-old woman who suffered brain damage as a result of a truck accident

$30,700,640.00 – traumatic brain injury of a 10-year-old child, wrongful death of an 11-year-old twin, and psychological trauma to the surviving twin as a result of failure to warn the children of a hazardous condition on the defendant’s property

$30,000,000.00 – husband injured when hit by a semi-truck, causing brain damage, fractured pelvis, fractured ribs, and fractured spine.

$25,000,000.00 – traumatic brain injury sustained in an auto accident.

$12,000,000.00 – Illinois medical malpractice birth injury case regarding brain damage and cerebral palsy as a result of the doctor and hospital’s failure to monitor fetal distress and stop the administration of Pitocin, resulting in lack of oxygen to the brain

$12,000,000.00 – physically and mentally handicapped man who suffered third-degree burns when placed in scalding hot water by a home care agency resulting in additional brain damage due to complications from the burns

$10,800,000.00 – rear-end semi-truck accident resulting in a mild traumatic brain injury to a college student

$9,600,000.00 – Illinois medical malpractice birth injury case resulting in brain damage and cerebral palsy

$8,000,000.00 – in a case of first impression in Indiana, the plaintiff was able to establish liability against a trucking broker for a rear-end truck accident resulting in paralysis. The trucking company was small, with only $1 million in insurance coverage, prompting the plaintiff to look for unique avenues of recovery

$7,650,310.00 – traumatic brain injury due to semi-truck accident

$7,500,000.00 – semi-truck accident causing mild traumatic brain injury, broken wrist, broken ribs, and collapsed lung

$7,100,000.00 – woman was injured in an accident with a semi-truck where she suffered a mild traumatic brain injury with resulting memory and problem-solving impairments

$6,195,000.00 – failure to place proper warning signs, barricades, or barriers, as required by the Manual of Uniform Traffic Control resulting in a car driving off bridge that had been demolished resulting in death of wife

$6,000,000.00 – wrongful death of a mother due to a semi-truck accident

$6,000,000.00 – policy limit settlement for a young woman who suffered multiple fractures in a car accident, including an open book pelvic fracture  

$5,750,000.00 – truck accident resulting in multiple fractures and a traumatic brain injury

$5,542,000.00 – wrongful death of a husband and father due to an industrial accident

$5,000,000.00 – policy limit settlement for the wrongful death of a mother and closed head injury to a child due to a semi-truck accident

$5,000,000.00 – wrongful death of a mother due to medical malpractice

$4,750,000.00 – young man slipped and fell at a gas station, causing shoulder injury and traumatic brain injury

$4,600,000.00 – industrial accident where cylinder gas cart fell on young man’s leg, causing nerve damage, vascular damage, and breaking multiple bones

$4,500,000.00 – policy limits settlement for the wrongful death of a wife hit by a semi-truck

$4,000,000.00 – young girl struck on her moped, causing head injury

$4,000,000.00 – wrongful death of a young woman hit by a semi-truck

$4,000,000.00 – semi-truck’s trailer came off while driving and crashed into plaintiff’s vehicle causing herniated disc and mild traumatic brain injury

$3,100,000.00 – wrongful death of a husband due to a semi-truck accident

$3,000,000.00 – wrongful death of a child due to an automobile accident

$3,000,000.00 – woman fell off stairs with no railing in violation of the building code, causing brain injury

$3,000,000.00 – auto accident resulting in complex regional pain syndrome (CRPS) and spinal cord simulator

$2,840,000.00 – car accident resulting in a herniated disc, nerve traction injury, and shoulder surgery

$2,830,000.00 – women suffered fractured femurs in car accident

$2,750,000.00 – rear-end car accident resulting in a herniated vertebral disc. The crash occurred at approximately 15 mph and the defendant’s final offer before trial was merely $80,000

$2,750,000.00 – side swipe accident resulting in herniated disc and ablations surgeries

$2,250,000.00 – semi-truck accident resulting in a mild traumatic brain injury

$2,250,000.00 – infiltration of an IV in the right arm resulting in permanent nerve damage and loss of use of the right hand to a 64-year-old car mechanic

$2,141,220.00 – negligent epidural injection during labor resulting in chronic neurologic pain and discomfort in the right leg

$2,000,000.00 – car accident resulting in an L2 vertebral burst fracture and surgery

$2,000,000.00 – rear-ended by semi-truck in Illinois, resulting in mild traumatic brain injury

$2,000,000.00 – truck accident resulting in concussion, neck injury, and back injury

$1,900,000.00 – truck/auto accident/disk injuries

$1,900,000.00 – wrongful death due to negligent dialysis care 

$1,750,000.00 – misdiagnosis of a trans ischemic attack (TIA) resulting in a stroke

$1,575,000.00 – improper dosage of medication to baby at NICU resulting in birth injury

$1,565,000.00 – failure to timely diagnose fetal distress and perform an emergency C-section resulting in the death of baby

$1,500,000.00 – policy limit settlement for father and two sons who were rear-ended, resulting in multiple injuries including torn rotator cuff, fractured spine, and concussion

$1,425,000.00 – death of a husband due to inadequate blood supply during by-pass heart surgery

$1,400,000.00 – a negligently stocked mirror fell on a woman’s neck while shopping resulting in a cervical fusion surgery

$1,400,000.00 – death of a wife caused by excessive administration of iron I.V. for anemia

$1,300,000.00 – negligent security resulting in a man being attacked, suffering a brain injury and dying

$1,250,000.00 – medical malpractice / wrongful death

$1,250,000.00 – medical malpractice / wrongful death

$1,250,000.00* – complication during delivery using vacuum extraction resulting in brain damage

$1,250,000.00 – failure to diagnose laryngeal cancer resulting in removal of larynx and impairment of speech

$1,250,000.00* – complications during delivery resulting in brain damage to the baby

$1,250,000.00* – cauda equina injury to the spinal cord due to failure to diagnose and treat a hematoma following surgery.

$1,250,000.00* – failure to diagnose and treat coronary artery disease resulting in death of a husband.

$1,250,000.00 * – negligent delay in performing cesarean section during failed VBAC with obvious fetal distress resulting in cerebral palsy and death of a newborn child

$1,250,000.00 * – inappropriate administration of Mobic, a platelet inhibitor, resulting in a bleed which caused damage to the spinal cord.

$1,250,000.00 * – failure to diagnose coronary artery disease resulting in the death of a husband and father of three.

$1,250,000.00 * – medical negligence during surgery resulting in blindness

$1,250,000.00 * – cerebral palsy of a baby due to negligent delivery and deprivation of oxygen resulting in brain damage

$1,250,000.00 * – cerebral palsy of a baby due to failure to properly monitor and diagnose fetal distress during labor, resulting in deprivation of oxygen and brain damage

$1,250,000.00 * – mild brain injury and cerebral palsy following birth complications

$1,250,000.00 * – mild brain injury and cerebral palsy due to a hospital’s failure to monitor fetal distress and stop the administration of Cervidil

$1,250,000.00 * – wrongful death of a father following angioplasty

$1,250,000.00 * – death of a wife due to misdiagnosis of cancer

$1,250,000.00 * – death of a husband and father due to the misdiagnosis of a cardiac condition

$1,250,000.00 * – misdiagnosis of cancer, which delayed treatment and shortened life expectancy

$1,250,000.00 * – numbness and weakness due to the improper placement of a spinal cord stimulator

$1,250,000.00 * – death of a child with meningitis due to the failure to administer antibiotics in the Emergency Room

$1,250,000.00 * – death of a husband due to the failure to protect against blood clots following disc surgery

$1,250,000.00 * – wrongful death of a 4-year-old child due to the failure to provide proper antibiotics after suffering a basilar skull fracture after a fall resulting in undiagnosed and untreated meningitis

$1,250,000.00 * – complications occurring during an angioplasty resulting in the death of a husband and father of two

$1,225,000.00 – the death of a mother due to improper intubation in the Emergency Room

$1,225,000.00 – misdiagnosed a trans ischemic attack (TIA) in a 74-year-old man as Bells palsy resulting in a stroke and loss of use of the right side of his body

$1,225,000.00 – failure to diagnose and properly treat the hypotensive patient in septic shock with IV fluids and appropriate medication resulting in the death of a mother

$1,220,000.00 – failed to diagnose classic symptoms and risk factors of trans ischemic attack (TIA), failed to admit into hospital, failed to treat resulting in stroke and left-sided hemiparesis

$1,211,844.00 – death of an elderly wife due to the failure to recognize an air embolus during hip replacement surgery

$1,200,000.00 – wife died because of pulmonary cement emboli during surgery

$1,200,000.00 – delay in diagnosing recurrent ovarian cancer resulting in a reduced life expectancy of a mother and wife.

$1,200,000.00 – failure to properly monitor blood pressure during shoulder surgery resulting in blindness in the right eye

$1,200,000.00 – loss of an eye due to golf course injury

$1,200.000.00 – policy limit settlement for the wrongful death of a 62-year-old housewife who was killed as a result of a drunk driver crossing the center line

$1,187,500.00 – paralysis of the diaphragm due to damage of the phrenic nerve during surgery

$1,187,500.00 – improper position during surgery resulting in permanent nerve damage in the arm

$1,187,500.00 – nurse improperly flushed porta Cath with resulting air emboli and death

$1,174,000.00 – improperly performed elective surgery on a dialysis patient without checking potassium level, and the untreated hyperkalemia resulted in cardiac arrest and death

$1,165,000.00 – death of a child due to surgical complications

$1,150,000.00 – death of a child due to the misdiagnosis of a shunt obstruction

$1,150,000.00 – damage to the trachea and esophagus due to improper intubation

$1,150,000.00 – 21-month delay in diagnosing lung cancer with denial of proper treatment resulting in the reduction of life expectancy of a 78-year-old man

$1,150,000.00 – wrongful death

$1,125,000.00 – failure to recognize a twin pregnancy causing a denial of proper care and treatment resulting in the death of a twin

$1,110,961.00 – damage to the small bowel following abdominal surgery

$1,068,480.00 – impairment of vision in one eye due to a BB gun accident

$1,050,000.00 – total knee replacement with improper prosthesis inserted

$1,037,000.00 – medical malpractice/misdiagnosis

$1,015,840.00 – auto accident resulting in a shattered hip with pins, plates, and screws

$1,000,250.00 – product liability case where toilet bowl cleaner exploded, causing injury to both eyes and loss of vision

$1,000,000.00 – semi-truck accident resulting in neck and back injuries requiring steroid injections

$1,000,000.00 – policy limit settlement after client hit by a semi-truck which slid through a red light in icy conditions causing herniated disc which required cervical fusion surgery

$1,000,000.00 – policy limit settlement for 23-year-old killed by negligent pizza delivery driver

$1,000,000.00 – nerve damage to an arm due to improper IV infiltration.

$1,000,000.00 – policy limit settlement for gentlemen who suffered multiple broken bones in an automobile accident

$1,000,000.00 – policy limit settlement for woman who lost her hand in an accident with a truck

$1,000,000.00 – negligent horse confinement resulting in horses roaming at large and running over plaintiff, causing a complete distal bicep tendon rupture requiring surgery

$1,000,000.00 – elderly lady hit by a corporate vehicle resulting in rotator cuff tear and brain injury

$1,000,000.00 – car accident resulting in a traumatic brain injury

$1,000,000.00 – t-bone accident resulting in fractured wrist with surgery

$1,000,000.00 – rear-end by a tractor-trailer semi-truck resulting in a labrum tear of the hip and arthroscopic surgery

$1,000,000.00 – products liability

$1,000,000.00 – policy limit settlement for wife whose husband was killed by a semi-truck

$1,000,000.00 – policy limit settlement for widow who lost her husband in a house explosion

$990,000.00 – elderly man slipped and fell on water at a grocery store, causing a mild traumatic brain injury

$975,000.00 – 73 year-old man was rear-ended by a semi-truck resulting in a mild traumatic brain injury

$975,000.00 – truck / auto accident, leg fracture

$969,000.00 – young man was rear-ended by a semi-truck, causing back pain

$950,000.00 – train accident at the Mill resulting in death

$950,000.00 – death of elderly gentleman due to negligence of semi-truck driver

$937,000.00 – death of a 73-year-old husband due to medical negligence

$930,000.00 – semi-truck crash resulting in mild brain damage

$920,308.00 – failure to diagnose and properly treat coronary disease resulting in death

$867,500.00 – construction site accident where contractor negligently covered a stairwell opening with Styrofoam which caused plaintiff to fall approximately 12 feet and resulted in a severely fractured ankle with permanent impairment and loss of function.

$860,000.00 – for facial scars and impairment of hearing due to an auto accident

$855,000.00 – semi-truck accident resulting in the death of an elderly man

$855,000.00 – auto accident, wrongful death

$850,000.00 – defective stairs resulting in fall and fracture of the lumbar spine

$844,500.00 – industrial accident resulting in burns to arms and legs

$800,000.00 – Industrial accident-crushed fingers

$800,000.00 – medical Malpractice / wrongful hysterectomy

$795,000.00 – elderly man tripped and fell at a restaurant and fractured his leg

$775,000.00 – death of an elderly woman due to a semi-truck accident

$772,800.00 – loss of vision in one eye of a 70-year-old man due to negligent cataract surgery

$750,000.00 – husband rear-ended by a tractor-trailer semi-truck, causing shoulder injury

$750,000.00 – policy limits settlement for a mild traumatic brain injury caused by a semi-truck accident

$750,000.00 – rear-end car accident resulting in a herniated disc, facet syndrome, and myofascial pain syndrome

$750,000.00 * – delay in treating eye condition resulting in permanent impairment of vision

$750,000.00 * – death of a baby due to delay in delivery in response to fetal distress

$750,000.00 * – death of a mother due to damage to her bowel during gallbladder surgery

$750,000.00 * – death of a mother due to delay in Emergency Room care

$750,000.00 * – death of a husband due to the misdiagnosis of prostate cancer

$750,000.00 * – misplaced feeding tube resulting in infection of lungs requiring surgery

$750,000.00 * – negligent performance of an angioplasty resulting in a tear in the coronary artery

$750,000.00 * – death of a child due to improper intubation

$750,000.00 * – death of a father due to the misdiagnosis of colon cancer

$750,000.00 * – death of a husband due to negligent care in the Emergency Room

$750,000.00 * – failure to diagnose an enlarged heart on a chest x-ray resulting in death

$750,000.00 * – delayed performance of a c-section following fetal distress resulting in cerebral palsy to the baby

$750,000.00 * – failure to diagnose Wilson’s Disease (a liver disorder) resulting in a liver transplant

$750,000.00 * – negligent hiatal hernia surgery necessitating multiple subsequent surgeries

$750,000.00 * – failure to diagnose coronary artery disease resulting in death

$750,000.00 * – improper placement of a shunt resulting in hydrocephalus (fluid on the brain) and brain damage

$750,000.00 * – a pathologist misdiagnosed a tissue sample resulting in an unnecessary hysterectomy of a 47-year-old women

$750,000.00 – semi-truck accident resulting in low back injury

$750,000.00 – bicycle accident on railroad tracks causing fractured hip

$750,000.00 – rear ended accident with a commercial motor vehicle causing herniated disc

$712,500.00 – young man was struck by a negligent ambulance driver resulting in a broken leg

$690,000.00 – failure to diagnose coronary block resulting in a heart attack and permanent heart damage

$690,000.00 – improper performance of an abdominal surgery resulting in damage to the spleen, gallbladder, and digestive tract

$675,000.00 – improper closing of a sternum following open heart surgery resulting in death

$600,000.00 – side swiped by semi-truck causing neck injury

$600,000.00 – young man struck by a police vehicle resulting in facial lacerations and brain injury

$575,000.00 – construction site accident resulting in a fractured leg requiring pins and plates

$560,706.00 – injury to knees requiring arthroscopic surgery due to auto accident

$550,000.00 – rear-end car accident resulting in herniated/protruded disc

$550,000.00 – truck accident resulting in herniated/protruded disc

$550,000.00 – internal injuries and multiple fractures due to train accident

$550,000.00 – herniated disc because of an auto accident

$550,000.00 – industrial accident resulting in a compound fracture of the leg requiring pins and plates

$550,000.00 – death of an elderly man due to a doctor’s failure to diagnose and treat congestive heart failure

$529,376.00 – failure to diagnose a fracture of the cervical spine resulting in permanent numbness and loss of strength to the lower extremities

$525,000.00 – industrial accident resulting in electrical burns to both arms

$500,487.00 – failure to diagnose undisclosed fracture resulting in permanent damage to the hip necessitating a total hip replacement